Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Raisor's avatar

The answer is neutral, and both. Depends on the patient, the psychiatrist, and the drugs.

Maybe Lindsay Clancy's psych meds dissociated her? Maybe if she werent medicated, she would have killed her kids even faster?

There's an awful large number of mass shooters on psych meds, or in withdrawal from them. Prozac manufacturers settled a mass shooter victims case out of court in the 90s. Standard Gravure. Believe he was in withdrawal when it happened.

People don't need SSRIs. People need other people. But no one has time for anyone else. Gotta produce. Grandmas in the nursing home. Small children in daycare. Chasing dollars and status costs us a lot. Our culture is very imbalanced.

Victor Perton's avatar

Thank you, Adam. I found this a powerful and genuinely thought-provoking article.

Australia may offer an interesting case for examining your argument.

The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, our independent statutory agency for national health and welfare information, reports that antidepressants were dispensed through Australia’s Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme to 139 people per 1,000 in 2024–25, up from 120 per 1,000 in 2015–16. Australia’s PBS makes prescribed medicines comparatively accessible and affordable, and general practitioners write most mental-health prescriptions.

At the same time, the measured prevalence of mental disorder among Australians aged 16–24 rose from 26% in 2007 to 39% in 2020–22. Importantly, this was not simply a survey asking young people whether they felt mentally unwell. It came from a structured national diagnostic survey using broadly comparable criteria.

So something substantial appears to have changed.

What we do not yet know is exactly what.

Are we identifying genuine suffering that was previously missed? Has underlying distress increased? Have our diagnostic boundaries widened? Has greater mental-health awareness changed the way ordinary distress is interpreted? Does easier access to medication produce more appropriate treatment, longer prescribing, greater medicalisation, or some mixture of all three?

And there is a further question I find particularly important: how do we recognise and treat genuine illness while also strengthening people’s confidence in their capacity to face difficulty, recover, adapt and flourish?

Australia’s experience does not answer your question. It makes the question even more worth asking.

Thank you for prompting it.

Ready for more?