The Psychology of Progress

The Psychology of Progress

Consent is not enough.

How one night in Ithaca became a national sexual reckoning.

Adam Omary's avatar
Adam Omary
Oct 07, 2026

Most sexual assaults in America are never reported to police, and few of those that are ever reach the national news. A generation ago, an allegation like the one now unfolding at Cornell might have been swept under the rug, if it surfaced at all. Instead it has drawn the attention of The New York Times and politicians across the nation, including the governor of New York. Why?

In October 2024, a sophomore at Cornell went to a party at the Chi Phi fraternity house, became intoxicated, and had sex with several men. Last month she sued the university and her alleged assailants. The university has since expelled two of the men through its Title IX process. This week, the county district attorney, who had initially declined to bring charges, reopened their investigation after prompting from Governor Kathy Hochul, the media frenzy, and learning that their office never received the police interview in which the student, known in court filings as Jane Doe, said she was raped.

Meanwhile, the Times obtained hundreds of pages from the Title IX file that complicate the story. After the party, Jane described the night to her roommates without calling it assault. She later assured one of the accused men that nothing sexual that night had been illegal. What seemed to distress her most was the gossip—rumors calling her a slut, which she asked friends to deny. After being disinvited from the next Chi Phi party, she replied bitterly that, “The woman will always get the short end of the stick.” Jane then encountered an anonymous post online alleging that the fraternity had drugged and gang-raped a student. That, she told investigators, was “the first time I had ever heard the narrative change that I wasn’t a whore and that I was assaulted.” By November her story morphed into one in which she was the victim of rape, intoxicated past the point of consent.

Jane Doe certainly was a victim, but perhaps not of clear-cut sexual assault.

Readers predictably sorted into two camps. To many feminists, it is a referendum on the dangers of Greek life, and how trauma can lead to delayed or confused reporting of sexual assaults, frustrated by a system that blames victims. To many conservatives, it reads as regret laundered into an accusation that thwarts due process. To both sides, it reads as different forms of a miscarriage of justice, and a culture that does not know how to talk about the boundaries of consent.

Deciding what really happened is the job of investigators and, perhaps, a jury. But the public debate is not really about that one night. The story serves as the latest spectacle in a growing gendered divide in culture and politics, and two incompatible lies we tell young people about sex.

The first lie, told mostly by the cultural left, is that sex is morally weightless, or even something to be unbridledly celebrated, so long as everything was consensual. Young women are told, and shown in fictional media such as Sex and the City (written by men), that men and women experience casual sex in the same way, and that it would be an affront to feminism to not embrace women’s hard-won sexual freedom. Advocating for caution, prudence, and the necessity of emotional bond before entering into a sexual relationship is a fine line into slut-shaming, and a slippery slope toward regressive paternalism.

This rooftop party scene will always be one of my favorites! It makes me  appreciate my girl friends. : r/sexandthecity
Sex and the City (1998-2004) glamorized casual sex among women. But the show was produced by men.

The second lie, told mostly by religious conservatives, is that the old order of stigma kept women safe, that shame is how a decent society protects its daughters. What went wrong began with the sexual revolution, they argue, and a culture that normalizes drinking, partying, and casual sex, rather than the conduct of particular men. A woman who goes upstairs at a fraternity party has written her own ending, and holding men to a standard of decency beyond what the law requires risks a slide toward the presumption of guilt.

Both sides hold a truth that exposes the other’s lies.

Feminists are right that many young women are exploited and misled, though much of that misleading has been brought on by their own side, in a way that enables exploitation. Modern culture told them, through countless television plots and campus orientation sessions, that consent exhausts the whole of sexual ethics. Then women discover that the sexual marketplace does not work that way. The gossip arrives. The men ghost them. They feel worse than they were promised they would, and too often they think they are the problem, because hookup culture seems to be working for everyone else. Wait, no it doesn’t, but isn’t it unfeminist of us to say so?

Conservatives, for their part, are right that men and women differ, and that sexual choices carry moral consequences. Regret, however sincere, is not a crime. Advising young women to be careful about where and how much they drink is no more victim-blaming than advising people to lock their doors or exercise street smarts at night. But shame and prudence have never been much of a shield. The era of chaperones for mixed-gender events was also the era in which allegations like this one were swept under the rug, and silence remains the norm: in the Justice Department’s National Crime Victimization Survey, roughly four in five rapes and sexual assaults of female college students went unreported to police.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from The Psychology of Progress.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 Adam Omary · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.